In journalism, it begins and ends with credibility. It’s what allows news organizations to rise above the noise of online chatter. Unfortunately, it seems that in the effort to chase traffic and capitalize on viral content, media companies are propagating misinformation far more often than they are debunking rumours. According to Craig Silverman’s report for the Tow Center, many news organizations don’t go far enough when reporting unverified claims. Once an unverified story gets picked up by the press, the public assumption is that it’s true. You might recall the errors in reporting the Boston bombing. But because hoaxes and rumours don’t need journalists to propagate, Silverman concludes newsrooms can’t just sit on the sidelines. We’ll talk about Silverman’s report on this week’s Mediatwits podcast with Craig Silverman, founder of Emergent.info and fellow at the Tow Center for Digital Journalism at Columbia University; Michael Calderone, senior media reporter at the Huffington Post; Jay Hathaway, staff writer at Gawker; and George Kelly, former editor for the Bay Area News Group. We’ll be joined this week by regular Andrew Lih of American University. PBS MediaShift’s Mark Glaser will host and Jefferson Yen will be producing.
Don’t have a lot of time to spare but still want to listen to the Mediatwits? Then check out our new Digital Media Brief below!
Mediatwits: Full Episode
Digital Media Brief
Listen to the Mediatwits and follow us on SoundCloud!
Thanks to SoundCloud for providing audio support.
Subscribe to the Mediatwits audio version via iTunes.
Follow @TheMediatwits on Twitter.
Subscribe to our YouTube Channel.
Mark Glaser is executive editor of MediaShift and Idea Lab. He is a longtime freelance writer and editor, who has contributed to magazines such as Entertainment Weekly, Wired and Conde Nast Traveler, and websites such as CNET and the Yale Global Forum. He lives in San Francisco with his wife Renee and son Julian. You can follow him on Twitter @mediatwit.
Andrew Lih is a new media journalist and associate professor of journalism at the American University School of Communication. He is the author of “The Wikipedia Revolution” (Hyperion 2009, Aurum UK 2009) and is a noted expert on online collaboration and journalism. He is a veteran of AT&T Bell Laboratories and in 1994 created the first online city guide for New York City (www.ny.com). Follow him on Twitter @fuzheado.
Michael Calderone is the Senior Media Reporter for The Huffington Post and has previously covered the press and politics for Politico, Yahoo News, and The New York Observer. He’s discussed media issues on CNN, MSNBC, NPR, and Al Jazeera English. Calderone is also an adjunct journalism professor at New York University, currently teaching a course on media criticism. Follow him @
Jay Hathaway is a staff writer for Gawker.com, in charge of Gawker’s Antiviral blog. He is a former editor of the Daily Dot, Download Squad and Urlesque, and a former writer for The Daily What. He may have been the first person to tweet about twerking. You can find him @
George Kelly is a journalist, blogger, musician and fan whose experience in print and online journalism, and with Web 2.0 racial and ethnic representation, helps forge and sustain diverse communities of affiliation and interest. He has written for Salon.com and The Industry Standard, and contributed to panel and feature presentations for South by Southwest Interactive Conference and Journalism Innovations. He tweets @
Craig Silverman is the founder of Regret the Error, a blog that reports on media errors and corrections, and trends regarding accuracy and verification. Craig has been a columnist for the Toronto Star, Columbia Journalism Review, The Globe And Mail and BusinessJournalism.org. He’s the former managing editor of PBS MediaShift, and was part of the team that launched OpenFile.ca, a Canadian online news start-up. His journalism and books have been recognized by the Mirror Awards, National Press Club, Canadian National Magazine Awards, and the Canadian Online Publishing Awards. You can find him @
Some of Silverman’s suggestions to curb the spread of online rumors are surprisingly simple. For example, outlinking should be done after claims are verified. Even large media organizations have been taken in by hoaxes on fake news sites. Ubiquity, confirmation bias and a lack of refutation are what give rumours traction. Once they do gain traction, they’re hard to squash. In the case of the National Report’s Banksy hoax, many publications had to debunk the rumor before the truth was shared more than the hoax.
In the rush to cover breaking news, journalists can and do make mistakes. Sometimes the consequences of those mistakes can be severe. Perhaps, it would be wise for readers to follow John Dickerson’s advice following the Boston bombings: “The standard that fits the breaking news moment is to treat everything as provisional and accept the error inherent in the speed that you’re demanding.”
How do you approach the news you see on social media? What are ways you believe journalists and news organizations can improve? Do words like “reportedly” make you question the veracity of an article or claim?
Jefferson Yen is the producer for the Mediatwits Podcast. His work has been on KPCC Southern California Public Radio and KRTS Marfa Public Radio. You can follow him @jeffersontyen.