As Arts Criticism Transforms Online, Tools and Tenacity Are Required

    by Gary Moskowitz
    March 4, 2014
    Photo by Kevin Jaako on Flickr and used here with Creative Commons.

    A few months ago, Bloomberg laid off its theater critic and dismantled its culture desk to focus simply on “luxury.” USC’s Annenberg School is shutting down its Getty Arts Journalism fellowship program. Harvard’s Nieman Fellowship in Arts & Culture Reporting no longer exists. In recent years, the Village Voice fired its film critic and the Washington Post nixed its standalone book reviews section. The great film critic Roger Ebert of the Chicago Sun-Times passed away last spring. Attendance at museums, ballet, opera, classical, and jazz concerts continues to decline.

    Because of these and many other reasons, it’s not exactly the most desirable, sexy, nor lucrative time to be an arts and culture writer or reporter.

    "Smart culture conversation online strives to evaluate the relevance and meaning of art, a lifestyle trend, a film, or piece of music. "

    And yet art continues to happen, and millions of people worldwide continue to consume it in myriad ways and through more outlets (YouTube) and platforms (Tumblr blogs, Twitter feeds), and devices (tablets, smartphones). Reports claim the entertainment industry is growing, and a broad, optimistic look at the music industry shows growth, not decline. Those of us who pay attention and are engaged in the larger conversation about arts and culture soldier on as best we can, and we do so more and more on the web.


    More competition, but more tools too


    Blogs and tweets enable anyone with Internet access and an opinion to write reviews, and publications like the Guardian solicit reader reviews on new music, so we have more competition. It’s exciting to see more people giving their opinions on art, food, and culture — with more voices comes more competition to be heard. How do we rise above the din? Tenacity and tools.

    More in-depth, analytical culture discussion happens on podcasts and audio documentaries, in long-form narratives, in sometimes annoying but often clever lists and quizzes.

    Matt Tucker / Via BuzzFeed

    Matt Tucker / Via BuzzFeed

    Smart culture conversation online strives to evaluate the relevance and meaning of art, a lifestyle trend, a film, or piece of music. That conversation comes not in the form of endorsements (“must see!”) or binary thumbs-up/thumbs-down judgments, but truthful, provocative, clever reasoning of precisely what any piece of culture is aiming to do and how it’s doing it.

    This happens in 142-character tweets that evoke clear meaning and link to evidence of what’s being discussed. It happens with purposeful headlines that serve the story rather than misrepresent it. It happens by way of rich multimedia that immerses us in the art itself, in open, online community dialog with the artists themselves, in lengthy conversations, and through visualized data investigation.

    The tricky part is that no one does this work for us or tells us precisely what story to tell or how to tell it. The platforms, apps, and devices are there, but it’s up to us to figure out precisely how to use these tools to render something useful for readers, users, and people interested in how art and culture is evolving.

    And at the end of the day, there’s no “gaming the system” in producing content about culture online. Shortcuts and tricks aimed at getting clicks may help drive readers to your site, but what happens when they get there? How long will they stay? Is there a sufficient, consistent amount of truth in the culture conversation they find there?

    Gary Moskowitz is a freelance arts & culture writer and reporter based in San Francisco. He writes for the Economist and SF Weekly, and has written for TIME magazine, the New York Times, Mother Jones, Newsweek, San Francisco Magazine, and other publications. He teaches journalism at California State University, East Bay. On March 25-26, he will lead the workshop “Arts & Culture Storytelling on the Web: Creating an Authentic, Meaningful, & Consistent Narrative Voice Online”at kdmcBerkeley at the Graduate School of Journalism UC Berkeley.

    Tagged: arts and culture arts reporting blogs celebrities conversation ellen film reviews oscars reviews twitter

    One response to “As Arts Criticism Transforms Online, Tools and Tenacity Are Required”

    1. Reiner Torheit says:

      The USA is a Neanderthal nation.

  • Who We Are

    MediaShift is the premier destination for insight and analysis at the intersection of media and technology. The MediaShift network includes MediaShift, EducationShift, MetricShift and Idea Lab, as well as workshops and weekend hackathons, email newsletters, a weekly podcast and a series of DigitalEd online trainings.

    About MediaShift »
    Contact us »
    Sponsor MediaShift »
    MediaShift Newsletters »

    Follow us on Social Media