Environmental Reporting Becomes Hazardous Work in Egypt, China

    by Clothilde Le Coz
    September 14, 2009
    Image of Songhua River fisherman via pacificenvironment.org

    Since May 2009, Tamer Mabrouk has held one of the saddest records regarding human rights abuses in Egypt. He is the first blogger to receive a fine after a company sued him for having criticized its activities in Lake Manzala, which is connected to the Suez Canal. Mabrouk was fined $8,700, lost his job, and was forced to move out of Port Said where he had been leaving for years.


    Tamer Mabrouk


    Mabrouk’s offense was that he blogged about the pollution the Trust Chemicals Company was dumping into Manzala Lake. Perhaps because they were afraid — or corrupt — the local authorities did not investigate the issue after Mabrouk brought it to light. So, with a few clicks, he decided to publish pictures proving the detrimental effect of the Trust Chemicals Company. In June 2008, the company sued him for defamation.

    “I tried to sue the company myself to ask for its closure,” Mabrouk said in a video posted on YouTube. “But the local court argued it did not have the jurisdiction to decide on that matter. Meanwhile, the Trust Chemicals Company was offering me money in return for my silence. I turned it down. Now, they want me to publish a denial.”

    (You can read more about Mabrouk’s case at the Reporters Without Borders site.)


    Environmental Writers Locked Up

    Mabrouk is by no means the only person to suffer for reporting about environmental disasters. Reporters in different parts of the world deal with fines, jail and threats as a result of their work.

    In China, for example, environmental activists often face repression after they gain the attention of international media. In July 2009, the anti-nuclear activist Sun Xiaodi and his daughter were sentenced to two years in a labor camp for “divulging state secrets abroad” and “publishing rumors.” Their crime? Publishing information online about the contamination of inhabitants of Gansu Province, which was caused by a Uranium 792 mine. Sun Xiaodi also published articles on corrupt officials of the Diebu district. For more than 20 years, Sun Xiaodi, a former worker in the Uranium 792 mine, has been fighting to raise awareness about the contamination.

    Another environmental activist, Wu Lihong, received a three-year prison sentence for warning Chinese and international media about pollution in Lake Taihu, which is the third largest lake in China.

    Aside from punishing those who speak out, the government also attempts to restrict the flow of critical health information. In 2005, the Chinese Propaganda Department, the government body that is also in charge of censorship, waited 10 days before authorizing the press to report about the benzene pollution threatening the Songhua river in Northeast China, completely disregarding the millions of people who live there.

    Threats and obstacles

    The environment is one of the biggest issues of our time. In order to preserve nature, we must be able to evaluate the resources we have left, and examine how they are being used. This kind of data helps inform society and influence political leaders to create new standards. It’s essential that specialists and environmental reporters are able to provide accurate information about the world around us. Unfortunately, journalists and bloggers are facing more and more obstacles and threats as they go about their work.

    Sometimes, a single visit by a journalist at a sensitive location is enough to spark a crisis. As an example, Cambodia has lost half of its forests over the last 15 years. After the organization Global Witness released reports on the situation, three journalists investigated the issue and subsequently received death threats. Their reporting revealed unflattering details about the involvement of relatives of the head of the government, Hun Sen. His brother, Hun Neng, said if anyone from Global Witness came to Cambodia, he would “beat his head up until it breaks.”

    i-713a4cf61b5c2f2212eb271f38eca3b5-radio free asia.jpg

    Lem Piseth, a journalist from Radio Free Asia, also received death threats as a result of his work. “About the story of the forest; I want you to know that you won’t find enough land there to bury you,” he was told. Piseth was forced to flee the country.

    In undemocratic countries, bloggers and reporters are often left to fend for themselves, which is why it’s so important that their work is recognized and publicized.

    Clothilde Le Coz has been working for Reporters Without Borders in Paris since 2007. She is now the Washington director for this organization, helping to promote press freedom and free speech around the world. In Paris, she was in charge of the Internet Freedom desk and worked especially on China, Iran, Egypt and Thailand. During the time she spent in Paris, she was also updating the “Handbook for Bloggers and Cyberdissidents,” published in 2005. Her role is now to get the message out for readers and politicians to be aware of the constant threat journalists are submitted to in many countries.

    Tagged: cambodia china egypt environmentalism freedom of speech

    4 responses to “Environmental Reporting Becomes Hazardous Work in Egypt, China”

    1. JohnAtl says:

      On a bus trip from the airport to downtown Xi’an in China, I thought the bus had an exhaust leak. Turns out the air is just that polluted. You see houses along the road, and the cooling towers of a power plant not too far behind them. What an environmental nightmare.

    2. Maire says:

      A friend visited China a year or two ago. She told me when she returned that not only was she offered the meats of endangered species as food, offerings which were clearly meant to impress her, but she also suffered terribly from the air quality in both Beijing and Hong Kong. She said that her lips and skin literally burned from the levels of sulphur in the air.

    3. Sokobanja says:

      Oh no, this is disaster. I live in ecological enviroment, so things like this means death to me.

    4. Dave Decker says:

      The U.S is not without it’s own long-term ‘ecological’/economic disasters…I have been posting on a local disaster here in Central California and all I get in return is that I am a “Fruit, Nut, or Tree-hugger”…While I HAVE hugged a tree or two in my life-time, I am VERY concerned about what this (and former) generation(s) is/are leaving to future generations (our own offspring). There is ‘criminal’ activity going on and I aim to disclose the perps and the reasons for their ‘deeds’…It is pretty ‘simple’, but most people are satified w/ the current status quo and are fearful of ‘rocking the agricultural boat’…I have worked in it and am fearful of NOT exposing it for what it is… a scam that costs all of us way too much (back-end and ‘up-front’)

  • Who We Are

    MediaShift is the premier destination for insight and analysis at the intersection of media and technology. The MediaShift network includes MediaShift, EducationShift, MetricShift and Idea Lab, as well as workshops and weekend hackathons, email newsletters, a weekly podcast and a series of DigitalEd online trainings.

    About MediaShift »
    Contact us »
    Sponsor MediaShift »
    MediaShift Newsletters »

    Follow us on Social Media