Building Great Data Tools Is Not Enough

    by Raymond Joseph
    November 25, 2015
    Photo from Andrew Carr via Flickr.

    “If you build it, they will come” is the classic line uttered by the character played by Kevin Costner in the 1989 hit movie “Field of Dreams.” It tells the story of an Iowa farmer who keeps hearing voices telling him to plough up his corn fields and build a baseball stadium in the middle of nowhere.

    He believes that if he does so, the Chicago White Sox team will come to his arena to play. So he does, and they do.

    But sadly the Hollywood fantasy-drama with a perfect outcome is worlds apart from the real-life world of tech where things don’t neatly follow a script to end on a happy note. All too often powerful, simple-to-use data tools for journalists are built and, after an initial buzz, they end up hardly being used by the very users they target.

    Siyazana provides users with a tool to investigate the connections that exist between the private and public spheres in South Africa.

    Siyazana provides users with a tool to investigate the connections that exist between the private and public spheres in South Africa.

    Social media and journalism sites and communities are great in helping to get the word out, but with new tools constantly popping up, some really good ones get lost in the traffic because little or no thought is given to outreach, marketing and training of potential users.

    Stuck in Traffic

    An example of this is the powerful Siyazana influence tracker built by former Knight Fellow Friedrich Lindenberg, which connects politicians and their money and business interests. Initially it did not receive the attention it deserved, but since being included in workshops on data journalism, it has become a go-to research tool for South African political journalists and researchers.


    code4sa_logoThis issue is central to the work of Code for South Africa (Code4SA) where I am currently embedded as an ICFJ Knight Journalism Fellow as part of an ICFJ/Code for Africa initiative that is using data journalism and civic engagement tools to empower Africans and improve their lives.

    The organization actively engages with potential journalism users to introduce them to tools for journalists developed by Code4SA, such as Wazimap, OpenByLaws, People’s Assembly and Bill Tracker.

    At the same time, Code4SA pursues a “catch-them-young” strategy, working with journalism schools and offering free tools and data journalism training for their students. This has led to relationships with journalism departments at universities that, in many cases, will result in these tools being incorporated into the curriculum.

    Time for Impact

    On another front, Code4SA principal technologist Greg Kempe is working with the Southern African Geography Teachers Association to introduce Wazimap as a practical teaching aid in classrooms. Wazimap, which makes elections and census data easily available to users with no tech skills, was refined and data added based directly on user feedback. Kempe is working closely with teachers to create lesson plans that enable students to use the tool for practical exercises and projects.

    Kempe says the tools developed by Code4SA are designed to have impact. “That means knowing who you are targeting and communicating to them what the opportunities and possibilities are. It also means being alive to opportunities to introduce these tools in communities you never thought of. It involves incorporating user feedback as part of the development process, not as something that happens at the end when the project is over and budget has been used up.”

    To achieve this it means budgeting up front to create instructional videos, and blogging and using social media and interactive sites to showcase what the tools do, he says.

    “If people don’t know about the tools you develop and you’re not actively telling them why they should care, what problems it will solve for them and how it can make their lives easier, then no matter how good the tech, nothing will happen.”

    Raymond Joseph (@rayjoe) is an ICFJ Knight Fellow working with Code for South Africa to strengthen the storytelling and audience engagement of news through data journalism and civic innovation in South Africa as part of ICFJ’s Code for Africa data journalism initiative. Joseph is a veteran of South African newsrooms, where he has worked in senior editorial and executive positions on a wide variety of daily and weekly national and regional publications.

    ijnetThis post originally appeared on the International Journalists’ Network. IJNet delivers the latest on global media innovation, news apps and tools, training opportunities and expert advice for professional and citizen journalists worldwide. Produced by the International Center for Journalists, IJNet follows the shifting journalism scene from a global perspective in seven languages – Arabic, Chinese, English, Persian, Portuguese, Russian and Spanish. Follow along on Twitter, Facebook or with IJNet’s free weekly newsletter.

    Tagged: big data code for south africa data data analysis ijnet

    Comments are closed.

  • Who We Are

    MediaShift is the premier destination for insight and analysis at the intersection of media and technology. The MediaShift network includes MediaShift, EducationShift, MetricShift and Idea Lab, as well as workshops and weekend hackathons, email newsletters, a weekly podcast and a series of DigitalEd online trainings.

    About MediaShift »
    Contact us »
    Sponsor MediaShift »

    Follow us on Social Media