Mediatwits #106: Twitter Storm Over Grantland Story About Transgender Golf Club Inventor

    by Claire Groden
    January 24, 2014
    Media ethicist Kelly McBride joined this week's podcast to discuss how Grantland bungled a story about a transgender woman

    Last week, ESPN’s Grantland published a story by Caleb Hannan called “Dr. V’s Magical Putter,” a piece that on its face looked into the ambitious claims of Essay Anne Vanderbilt (a.k.a. Dr. V), the inventor of a golf putter called Yar. The article ended up being less about a putter and more about the inventor and her secret about being a transgender woman. Dr. V had committed suicide months before the article was published and weeks after last speaking with the reporter. In the aftermath of the article, the reporter and Grantland have been widely attacked for prioritizing the story over compassion. Grantland’s editor-in-chief issued a point-by-point apology Monday in tandem with a piece titled “What Grantland Got Wrong” by an ESPN staff writer, Christina Kahrl, who is a transgender woman. This week on Mediatwits, we’re joined by special guest Poynter’s Kelly McBride to talk about the ethics of Grantland’s reporting, as well a Gawker’s features editor Tom Scocca, who wrote this piece about the controversy. We’ll also be joined by American University’s Andrew Lih, and as usual, PBS MediaShift’s Mark Glaser will host.

    Subscribe to the MediaShift audio podcast here.


    Listen to the Mediatwits and follow us on SoundCloud!

    Thanks to SoundCloud for providing audio support. Subscribe to the Mediatwits audio version via iTunes.

    Follow @TheMediatwits on Twitter.



    mark glaser ISOJ headshotMark Glaser is executive editor of MediaShift and Idea Lab. He is a longtime freelance writer and editor, who has contributed to magazines such as Entertainment Weekly, Wired and Conde Nast Traveler, and websites such as CNET and the Yale Global Forum. He lives in San Francisco with his wife Renee and son Julian. You can follow him on Twitter @mediatwit.


    AndrewLih_270x210Andrew Lih is a new media journalist and associate professor of journalism at the American University School of Communication. He is the author of “The Wikipedia Revolution” (Hyperion 2009, Aurum UK 2009) and is a noted expert on online collaboration and journalism. He is a veteran of AT&T Bell Laboratories and in 1994 created the first online city guide for New York City (www.ny.com). Follow him on Twitter @fuzheado.


    Kelly_McBride5smallKelly McBride has served as a faculty member of the Poynter Institute since 2002, acting as a teacher, writer and expert on media ethics. She is in charge of the Ethics Department and the Reporting, Writing and Editing Department at Poynter. Kelly is also the director of the Sense-Making Project under the Poynter Institute, which analyzes the transformation and values of journalism, as well as the relationship between technology and democracy. Kelly, in tandem with Tom Rosenstiel, co-edited the book The New Ethics of Journalism: Principles for the 21st Century.

    avt-largeTom Scocca is the features editor of Gawker. Previously, he was the “Off the Record” columnist and media editor for The New York Observer. Before that, he was an editor and writer for Washington City Paper and Baltimore’s City Paper. He writes the “Scocca” blog for Slate, and his byline appears regularly in The Boston Globe and The Awl.


    The reporter was undoubtedly working with a tough story: a profile of an inventor who fabricated most details she shared with him. She never attended MIT or Wharton or worked on top-secret government projects. But many commentators have criticized the article for conflating her dishonesty about her professional history with her desire to keep her gender identity private. The article was also denounced for outing Dr. V, even posthumously, since she had made her desire for privacy clear. Where does fact-finding end, and cruel privacy-encroachment begin? How should a reporter gauge which details are fair game, and which aren’t?


    Dow Jones Chief Resigns in Shift by News Corp. (NY Times)

    Why The Washington Post Passed on Ezra Klein (Politico)

    Teens Love Instagram But Aren’t Abandoning Facebook (GigaOm)

    How an Intern Created the NYT’s Dialect Quiz, the Site’s Most-Visited Content in 2013 (Knight Lab)

    Claire Groden is the podcast intern for PBS Mediashift and a senior at Dartmouth College. You can follow Claire on Twitter @ClaireGroden.

    Tagged: bill simmons caleb hannan dr. v espn essay anne vanderbilt grantland Kelly McBride poynter institute tom scocca transgender

    One response to “Mediatwits #106: Twitter Storm Over Grantland Story About Transgender Golf Club Inventor”

    1. Karen St John says:

      The best way to gauge an issue about a transgender (in this case transsexual) person is to ask. A transsexual person who didn’t advertise her back history did so because she didn’t wished to be mired in their old life. It isn’t fraudulent to leave it out of a paper, but it will create needless social devastation. Dr. V may have killed herself because of the actual frauds she did commit in her credentials, especially if they involved possible prosecution. We will never know because there was no note.

      There is a tropism in our society that makes transgender and transsexual lives out to be deceptive. This article served to further that prejudice. Had Caleb Hannan thought the matter enough to vet the article, he would have discerned how devastating this would be not just to Dr. V’s memory, but also to living TG/TS people, who transition to feel genuine in our own lives.

      The addition of the transgender aspect added nothing to the story of the fraud Dr. V committed, a very legitimate story. It did serve to reinforce the salacious opinions of certain segments of society about TG/TS people, and that, my dear friends, is why we are upset about this article.

  • Who We Are

    MediaShift is the premier destination for insight and analysis at the intersection of media and technology. The MediaShift network includes MediaShift, EducationShift, MetricShift and Idea Lab, as well as workshops and weekend hackathons, email newsletters, a weekly podcast and a series of DigitalEd online trainings.

    About MediaShift »
    Contact us »
    Sponsor MediaShift »
    MediaShift Newsletters »

    Follow us on Social Media