Journalist Faced Prison for Posting Media Relations Number

    by Geoffrey King
    December 2, 2013
    The Boston Police Department charged Miller for wiretapping. Photo by velkr0 on Flickr and used here with Creative Commons license.

    Carlos Miller is not one to back down. As the founder and publisher of Photography is Not a Crime, a leading blog about free speech and press rights in the U.S., Miller has made it his mission to publicize examples of government overreach and the suppression of journalists’ and other newsgatherers’ rights. And although he frequently finds himself taking law enforcement officials to task through a combination of original reporting, analysis and activism, Miller never expected that his work would lead to a criminal charge punishable by a decade’s imprisonment.

    Carlos Miller

    Carlos Miller

    "We are really open about what we do. And somebody has to hold [the government] accountable." -Carlos Miller.

    A veteran reporter, Miller has covered breaking news as both a full-time staff reporter and a freelancer with news organizations in several states, including several years on the police beat for the Arizona Republic. Miller founded Photography is Not a Crime after he was arrested for photographing a group of police officers while he was on assignment in Miami six years ago, an arrest for which he was ultimately vindicated. “I’m very careful of not breaking the law,” Miller told the Committee to Protect Journalists. “If I had broken a law, then I would just admit to it, ‘Okay, you got me,’ and then I would have to deal with the consequences. But if I’m not breaking the law, then I’m going to be very adamant about it. I’m going to stand up and fight it.”


    The story of how Miller came to face such a serious charge — which police dropped on Nov. 15 after a massive backlash from free expression advocates and members of the press — is as convoluted as it is improbable.

    Miller was charged with the crime of witness intimidation for a single statement he made in a blog post on Photography is Not a Crime.

    The post detailed an incident that led to a wiretapping charge against a student journalist with whom Miller is acquainted. The student, who police say recorded a Boston Police Department (BPD) spokesperson without her consent, was seeking comment about an unrelated video of a BPD sergeant who can be seen intimidating a videographer filming a detention from a public sidewalk. (The student disputes the allegation that he failed to secure consent; the charge against the student was also dropped on Nov. 15.)


    A telephone conversation with a BPD detective as relayed by Miller indicates that Miller’s ‘crime’ consisted solely of including within his blog post the main media relations phone number listed on the department’s website, the publicly-available email address of its spokesperson, and an admonition to Photography is Not a Crime readers to contact the spokesperson and ask that the department drop the charges against the student journalist. Miller says the same detective told him, “I can go and get warrants for every person who called” the spokesperson.

    Although BPD ultimately came to its senses and dropped the charge against Miller, the aborted prosecution nonetheless represents a strange turn of events in the U.S., where authorities have recently jailed a blogger and another journalist in relation to information they posted to the Internet. And while Miller’s case would be chilling anywhere, it is particularly difficult to reconcile with the speech and press guarantees of the U.S. Constitution.

    Regardless of where such censorship occurs, governments must understand that the Internet has subjected their actions to far wider scrutiny than ever before. Heavy-handed tactics now bring a real risk of public exposure and outrage. As a federal appeals court put it in ruling against BPD officers in 2011

    Moreover, changes in technology and society have made the lines between private citizen and journalist exceedingly difficult to draw. The proliferation of electronic devices with video-recording capability means that many of our images of current events come from bystanders with a ready cell phone or digital camera rather than a traditional film crew, and news stories are now just as likely to be broken by a blogger at her computer as a reporter at a major newspaper.

    That is why, to Miller, the most important virtue is transparency. “We are in a very new age because of technology, a very new age of journalism,” he says. Of government authorities, he notes, “We are really open about what we do. And somebody has to hold them accountable.”

    Requests for comment from BPD went unanswered.

    Geoffrey King coordinates the Committee to Protect Journalists’ Internet and technology policy efforts. King, who is based in San Francisco, protects the rights of journalists through advocacy, public education, and engagement with policymakers worldwide. Prior to joining CPJ, King, an attorney by training, represented U.S.-based individuals in constitutional matters involving the freedoms of speech, press, and petition. King is also a documentary photographer whose work has focused on human rights and social movements. In addition to his work as an advocate and journalist, King teaches courses at UC Berkeley on digital privacy law and policy, as well as the intersection of media and social change. King holds a bachelor’s degree in Mass Communications, Phi Beta Kappa and with Highest Distinction, from UC Berkeley. He earned his law degree from Stanford Law School. His public GPG encryption key can be found here. Follow him on Twitter @CPJInternet.

    cpj logo

    A version of this post originally appeared on CPJ’s Internet Channel. The Committee to Protect Journalists is a New York-based, independent, non-profit organization that works to safeguard press freedom worldwide. You can learn more at CPJ.org or follow the CPJ on Twitter @pressfreedom or on Facebook here.

    Tagged: ethics free speech wiretapping

    6 responses to “Journalist Faced Prison for Posting Media Relations Number”

    1. Ste Bunches says:

      Good. Goddamn right on! from every person whose life has been decimated by some lying lackwit of a badge wielding horse’s ass. I only wish there was more I could do to help.

    2. RH says:

      On the off chance that anyone from BPD ever reads this I would like to say that I live just south of Boston, and I can assure you this blatant abuse of power will cross my mind before I dial 911 in Boston. That translates to you in blue not getting a call, or getting a call after things turn REALLY ugly. I sure as hell won’t want to provide an assistance.

      Interestingly I don’t have that attitude with respect to the police in my town, or several other south shore towns….

      but then…
      I remember that noose. I remember blacks being searched when a white man shot his wife. and most importantly… I noticed that none of you. NOT ONE. arrested any of your fellow officers for this egregious breach of rights.

      These actions have a real measurable effect on your ability to do you job, the safety of the community, and officer safety. Each time we get a lesson in why we should fear the police, every interaction becomes a little bit more tense. Each time we are a little more hesitant to get the police involved. I don’t want that. I want to have a police force I trust so I know I can call on them to help with a situation without fear for myself or others.

      Most of you are probably great officers, but if I don’t call you when I see a possible crime… look down at your handcuffs and ask yourself if you really truly have never had a reason to put them on another officer… then explain to me why they are still on your belt.

    3. Robbie Moraes says:

      all I see is an internet geeks who likes to cause trouple. Nothing else.

      • Eric says:

        You sir, are what’s wrong with this country.

        Also, please learn to spell. Is there one internet geek, as in “an internet geek” or multiple internet geeks as in “internet geeks” (where the “an” is not necessary?

        Also, trouble is spelled with a b.

        Please also learn to capitalize the first letter of your sentences.

        You seem like the person who liked to “cause trouble” instead of paying attention in school.

      • Difdi says:

        And I bet you consider Stalin to have been a true visionary in the field of human rights.

    4. DavidShellenberger says:

      End government police. Government is the worst provider of any service, including security.

  • Who We Are

    MediaShift is the premier destination for insight and analysis at the intersection of media and technology. The MediaShift network includes MediaShift, EducationShift, MetricShift and Idea Lab, as well as workshops and weekend hackathons, email newsletters, a weekly podcast and a series of DigitalEd online trainings.

    About MediaShift »
    Contact us »
    Sponsor MediaShift »
    MediaShift Newsletters »

    Follow us on Social Media