Mediatwits #59: Special Roundtable on Hate Speech vs. Free Speech Online

    by Mark Glaser
    October 12, 2012
    The "Innocence of Muslims" video was temporarily pulled down in Libya and Egypt due to "very difficult circumstances" there, according to YouTube

    Welcome to the 59th episode of the Mediatwits podcast, with Mark Glaser and Rafat Ali as co-hosts. This week is a special edition of the podcast completely focused on the challenges of online services such as YouTube, Facebook and others who have to balance free speech and hate speech while serving global audiences. The latest example being “The Innocence of Muslims” video that was posted on YouTube, and temporarily removed in Libya and Egypt by the service, later having them restored. Was it the right decision or too little, too late? Our guests include the World Policy Institute fellow Susan Benesch, EFF’s Trevor Timm and legal scholar Jonathan Peters.

    How transparent should these companies be about their decisions on pulling content? Can they be expected to follow the letter of the law in every country? And what are the exceptions to their rules? We asked various companies to provide someone for the podcast, but Yahoo, Google/YouTube, Facebook and Twitter declined. However, YouTube reiterated its statement about the “Innocence of Muslims” video:

    [Innocence of Muslims] may have been offensive and disgusting and just plain weird but there was no incitement in the video. It was certainly provocative, but didn't call on people to rise up in violence." -Trevor Timm

    “We want YouTube to be a community everyone can enjoy as well as an important platform for free expression. This inevitably raises tensions over some videos because what is OK in one country may be controversial in another. As we have always made clear, this video [“Innocence of Muslims”] is within our community guidelines. We only restricted access to it in Libya and Egypt on a temporary basis due to the very difficult circumstances there. Now that the situation is calmer, we’ve reinstated the versions that had been restricted.”



    Subscribe to the podcast here


    Subscribe to Mediatwits via iTunes

    Follow @TheMediatwits on Twitter here

    Guest Bios

    Susan Benesch is Senior Fellow at the World Policy Institute in New York where she directs the Dangerous Speech Project. Benesch also teaches international human rights at American University’s School of International Service.

    i-8659db89bbb2db796b6224af939a204b-Benesch bio photo.jpg

    Susan Benesch

    Trevor Timm is an activist and blogger for the Electronic Frontier Foundation or EFF, where he specializes in free speech and government transparency issues. He has also contributed to The Atlantic, Al-Jazeera, The Guardian, Foreign Policy, and PBS MediaShift.

    Jonathan Peters is a media lawyer and the Frank Martin Fellow at the Missouri School of Journalism. He blogs about free speech for the Harvard Law & Policy Review, and he has written on legal issues for The Atlantic, Slate, Wired, The Nation, and PBS MediaShift, among others.

    Our show is now on Stitcher! Listen to us on your iPhone, Android Phone, Kindle Fire and other devices with Stitcher. Find Stitcher in your app store or at stitcher.com.

    Intro and outro music by 3 Feet Up; mid-podcast music by Autumn Eyes via Mevio’s Music Alley.

    Highlights from the Show


    1:00: Baseball fever vs. cricket fever

    2:45: Rafat’s experience with website blocking around the world

    3:40: India asked for content pull-downs on Orkut years ago

    i-25bd838f10f9e0ae02d6ab0fc2bb8299-trevor timm.jpg

    Trevor Timm

    Special roundtable on free speech vs. hate speech

    5:15: Intro to roundtable

    6:40: Special guests Susan Benesch, Trevor Timm and Jonathan Peters

    8:25: Benesch explains differences between hate speech and dangerous speech

    11:10: Can EFF help out startups dealing with free speech issues?

    13:00: Timm: Companies have outsized responsibility when it comes to speech online

    16:40: Peters: Companies operating on a global scale have to follow local laws in many countries

    22:15: Benesch: ‘Innocence of Muslims’ is not a work of art, and has no purpose other than to provoke Muslims

    i-c34cf3e19c88c01659a606ea6e0b637f-jonathan peters.jpg

    Jonathan Peters

    24:50: Timm: What about parodies by ‘South Park’ of Mohammed and Mormons?

    25:30: Benesch: YouTube can’t really “block” videos, because the content gets posted all over the web

    30:00: Peters runs down various other examples of content blocked around the world

    More Reading

    The Innocence of YouTube at Foreign Policy

    Google Transparency Report at Google

    When Censorship Makes Sense: How YouTube Should Police Hate Speech# at The New Republic

    Free Speech in the Age of YouTube at NY Times

    Free Expression and Controversial Content on the Web at Google Blog

    On the Web, A Fine Line on Free Speech Across Globe at NY Times

    Striking balance between free speech and ‘hate speech’ is Internet balancing act at The Wisconsin Techology Council

    Dangerous Speech: A Proposal to Prevent Group Violence by Susan Benesch

    MediaShift Poll

    Don’t forget to vote in our poll, this time about how YouTube should deal with controversial videos:

    Mark Glaser is executive editor of MediaShift and Idea Lab. He also writes the bi-weekly OPA Intelligence Report email newsletter for the Online Publishers Association. He lives in San Francisco with his son Julian and fiancee Renee. You can follow him on Twitter @mediatwit. and Circle him on Google+

    Tagged: censorship dangerous speech facebook free speech global media google hate speech innocence of muslims twitter youtube

    Comments are closed.

  • “The Collaboration of the Week” is a series of stories and podcast segments at MediaShift highlighting one important media collaboration and explaining how they did it. The series is sponsored by Airtable, the all-in-one collaboration platform for creative teams. Receive $50 in credit by visiting airtable.com/mediashift.

  • Who We Are

    MediaShift is the premier destination for insight and analysis at the intersection of media and technology. The MediaShift network includes MediaShift, EducationShift, MetricShift and Idea Lab, as well as workshops and weekend hackathons, email newsletters, a weekly podcast and a series of DigitalEd online trainings.

    About MediaShift »
    Contact us »
    Sponsor MediaShift »
    MediaShift Newsletters »

    Follow us on Social Media