How to Teach Yourself About Social Media When J-Schools Fail

    by Roland Legrand
    April 14, 2009
    A gathering of participants in the Connectivism Course, discussing a 3D presentation of the information flow in the course. Picture taken in Second Life by "Fleep Tuque":http://www.flickr.com/photos/fleep/2868707349/in/set-72157607368558947/ via Flickr

    Journalism is changing rapidly due to social media, and these changes can be bewildering as people wonder how to keep up. I recently gave a social media workshop for journalism students, and I soon realized that many students were still unaware of social media other than Facebook. They were shocked to hear about feed readers, blogs, or micro-blogging and asked how they could learn about all those developments.

    It seems that we should rethink not only journalism, but also journalism education: Tomorrow’s journalists will need to take the initiative to teach themselves about rapidly changing technology. To that end, here are some ways that students can become their own teachers in regards to social media.

    Tomorrow's journalists will need to take the initiative to teach themselves about rapidly changing technology."


    In both the social media workshops I have organized in our own newsroom and the workshop I held for journalism students, participants were bewildered by the diversity of what we call social media: blogs, micro-blogging, vlogs, forums, wikis…


    People also realize that not only are things changing rapidly but that the speed of change is also increasing. Some examples of radical change include:

    > The first news websites were nothing more than frequently updated online versions of their parent newspapers. Now those same sites are vibrant communities.

    > Readers do not necessarily reach the a web page by coming through the site’s home page; instead they come in through the stock quotes, through search engines, referring sites or feed readers.


    i-0eacc6449c2365e5259c65bbbc2a1943-jstudent grad.jpg

    Journalism grads must teach themselves about social media

    Colleagues and journalism students told me that they are not prepared for this. I realize my colleagues are extremely busy covering the financial crisis, and don’t have much time to study the continuous stream of innovations in social media. But I was more surprised to find that some major journalism schools, at least in Belgium, do not study social media. Students hardly know how to organize RSS feeds and have no idea how to use Twitter or Facebook in a newsroom context.

    Students as well as colleagues wanted to know how they could keep up with developments in social media while not neglecting what they see as their main job: covering the news, providing insights, and facilitating discussions.

    Crisis of journalism, crisis of education

    Today, the importance of Big Media in our democracies is being challenged. At the same time, the role of classical schools and universities is also in question.

    While educational institutions promote the idea of lifelong learning, they are not very flexible in facilitating such. This is not only a matter of inconvenient hours. It seems to me that educational institutions are focused on delivering certificates and evaluating their students. This model doesn’t make much sense in the case of adult, professionally active learners.

    Such learners often don’t care about certificates. The only real test will be whether they can actually use their new knowledge and skills at their jobs and businesses. In our case, will they be better journalists? Will they be able to demonstrate results in terms of page views, unique visitors, reactions and time spent?

    There are other venues now to get your news and analysis: blogs, Twitter feeds, virtual communities, social networks. Those same social media also make it possible to at least partially bypass the mainstream educational institutions. People often tell me that they learn more nowadays by writing a blog and engaging in blog conversations than that they could possibly learn in an old-school university setting.

    Models to become your own teacher

    The fundamental model of social media is that of collaboration. There are various ways to learn and teach by collaborating, but I would like to bring your attention to two broad categories.

    > Informal networked learning simply refers to using social media to acquire skills, knowledge and connections, on an ad hoc basis: Passions and projects may change, and so will one’s position in the learning network shift. Informal networked learning allows more “lurking behavior” as one could just observe, for instance, and not contribute anything at all. Of course, it might be wise to make come contributions to engage in some conversation, but the idea is very much that of a passing traveler, who may very well leave in the morning.

    A very interesting experiment in this regard was the Connectivism Course organized in 2008 and which will probably be repeated this year. According to the Wikipedia entry:

    The course was free and open to anyone who wished to participate, with over 2,000 people worldwide signing up. The phrase “Massively Open Online Course” was coined to describe this open model. All course content was available through RSS feeds, and learners could participate with their choice of tools: threaded discussions in Moodle, blog posts, Second Life, and synchronous online meetings.

    > Another way to learn through social media is through communities of practice. The community of practice is a group of professionals who invite apprentices to join them. The advantage for the students: They can find mentors who will not just explain technological tools, but will also introduce the students into the socio-cultural environment of the group — how journalists behave, what are their ethical principles, how journalists relate to other groups etc.

    i-59d49fd5f855833358c480bda4503429-howard rheingold.jpg

    Howard Rheingold

    In exchange, like in all communities, a certain reciprocity is expected: students and participants should be active, at least by commenting or asking questions, exchanging ideas. The relationships are also in this case pretty informal, but there is still a sense of apprenticeship that offers more support for those wishing to enter the professional community. An absolutely interesting person to follow in this context is Howard Rheingold and his Social Media Classroom.

    In the first case, just using informal networked learning, much depends on the skills and character that the individual learner has already acquired. If she is already mastering social media and has lots of experience in organizing her contacts in virtual communities, informal networked learning is a very natural thing to do. It is a matter of organizing relevant blogs in a feed reader, participating in online discussions, connecting to inspiring people using Twitter, Facebook, LinkedIn or virtual venues on Second Life.

    A key difference between networked learning and communities of practice is the former’s emphasis on the individual, rather than the group. In the community of practice, the individual is important as well, but there is more of an idea of engagement toward a community, which has an importance on its own.

    The second option seems particularly interesting for students or for those still unfamiliar with social media. Groups of journalists could form an informal community, inviting in journalism students, meeting in the physical world while also using social media, exchanging best practices, new ideas, interesting case studies.

    It should be clear that both options are not mutually exclusive, and most probably, if the community of practice functions well, people will gradually emancipate themselves and practice more informal networked learning, becoming even more valuable participants in the community of practice as they do so.

    Things to do

    Our newspapers belong to a larger publishing group. I do hope to find some opportunities to encourage like-minded colleagues to start a community of social media practice. In our newsrooms, we often have journalism students come to work with us as part of their training. It would be very interesting to invite those young people into our community of practice.

    Inevitably the issue will be whether the community should also open its virtual and physical doors for journalists from other, eventually competing, media groups. Would our publisher consider that “giving away” skills and knowledge to the competition, or would it be considered a collaborative model beneficial to all media participants?

    This is a bit of a cliffhanger here, but I do promise to keep you informed on further developments… Please share your thoughts and ideas in the comments with your own take on these alternative ways for people to learn about social media.

    Roland Legrand is in charge of Internet and new media at Mediafin, the publisher of leading Belgian business newspapers De Tijd and L’Echo. He studied applied economics and philosophy. After a brief teaching experience, he became a financial journalist working for the Belgian wire service Belga and subsequently for Mediafin. He works in Brussels, and lives in Antwerp with his wife Liesbeth.

    Photo of journalism school grad by InSunlight via Flickr; photo of Howard Rheingold by UOC_Universitat via Flickr.

    Tagged: communities of practice connectivism journalism school learning networked learning social media

    5 responses to “How to Teach Yourself About Social Media When J-Schools Fail”

    1. Haven’t read MediaShift in a while (the posts are always so long), but this one’s got some great information and suggestions that I’ll pass on to profs and students at my alma mater.

    2. Brian Colbert says:

      I am a journalism student at the University of Missouri and have been very frustrated with the school in the past on this exact subject. However recently, i’ve noticed a shift. They partnered with Newsy.com, an innovative social news outlet, and have started to pour more money into projects to prepare kids for the changes in the industry.

    3. alfonso todd says:

      I enjoyed article and found I had adopted some of these collabrative prctices witout even realizing it. I have several sites that I have created to establish my
      fledgling company, and it seems to be working,

      Alfonso Todd

    4. It is easy to be overwhelmed by all the technology. I have been online for several years, if you are trying to keep track of the sites and technology, you will go mad. It is a full time job.

      I would suggest that if you are passionate about your craft, work on that, good content can be difficult to find.

      If you really have true value to share with the world, it will travel virally on its own merit.

    5. Do you think about music?
      I like music very much.And i like
      musical instrument.

  • Who We Are

    MediaShift is the premier destination for insight and analysis at the intersection of media and technology. The MediaShift network includes MediaShift, EducationShift, MetricShift and Idea Lab, as well as workshops and weekend hackathons, email newsletters, a weekly podcast and a series of DigitalEd online trainings.

    About MediaShift »
    Contact us »
    Sponsor MediaShift »
    MediaShift Newsletters »

    Follow us on Social Media