Book Reveals What Students Really Think About College Professors, Teaching

    by Joe Grimm
    February 13, 2017
    The authors, from left, front row: Bryce Airgood, Meaghan Markey, Kelly Gooch, Erin Merlo and Alexandria Drzazgowski. Middle row: Nichole Igwe, Christina Briones, Nicole Kazyak, Natalie Kozma, Brittany Dreon and Andrew DiFilippo. Back row: Matthew Hus, Molly Jensen, Hannah Watts, Palak Sabbineni, Michelle Armstead and Eric Straughn. Not shown: Kim Al-Shatel. Photo by Joe Grimm

    The last thing I needed was to have my journalism class publish a book on how college teaching can be better. No one wants to be the smarty-pants prof who presumes to school colleagues on teaching. The fact is, we all struggle with it. My initial reaction was a knee-jerk no.

    As you might guess, the idea came out of a meeting I did not attend. Roiled by cultural calamities in the classroom, faculty members in the Michigan State University College of Communication Arts and Sciences decided a book could help profs know better.

    Our special sauce was that this book would look through student lenses. Several profs told us they would like to write books telling students how to do college. But there are plenty of books from that point of view and almost none by students.

    Journalism professor Howard Bossen suggested that my Bias Busters class do it. Bias Busters publishes books like “100 Questions and Answers About African Americans.” We published 11 through 2016. The books are meant to be conversation starters for people who want to learn from each other.


    University Investment

    When Associate Dean of Research Kami Silk offered to seek university funding for a book, I reversed course. We received $21,200 from the MSU Office of Inclusion and Intercultural Initiatives, mostly to buy copies of what we published.

    Our special sauce was that this book would look through student lenses. Several profs told us they would like to write books telling students how to do college. But there are plenty of books from that point of view and almost none by students.

    Cover of "To My Professor: Students Voices for Great College Teaching."We used statements by students across Michigan State University and other campuses as trailheads. Horror stories and hero stories would lead off each chapter. We called the book “To My Professor: Student Voices for Great College Teaching” and asked students to write notes they would like their profs to see. We used index cards, social media and interviews.


    “To My Professor…”

    The project was similar to one in which Colorado teacher Kyle Schwartz asked her third graders to write notes that begin, “I wish my teacher knew …” Schwartz said the key is to give students at every age a chance to say what is really on their minds and to hear them.

    Some comments were:

    “I spend a lot of money to go to school here. It would be nice if a professor knew my name.”

    “Why did I lose five points for turning in my assignment an hour late, but the guy sitting next to me faced almost no penalty for plagiarizing his paper off of the internet?”

    “When you respond to my explanation of my pronouns with your refusal to use them based on your opinion that they are ‘grammatically incorrect’ (which isn’t true), you are saying your views on grammar are more important than my comfort, my safety, and me as a person.”

    “Some of us veterans have extensive experience in the field you’re teaching and have valuable insight to contribute. I would appreciate for you to realize that veterans are in the room.”

    We Mined Twitter




    Were the comments, even the tweets, legit? Communication Arts and Sciences Associate Dean for Undergraduate Education Ann Hoffman said she had seen every situation reflected in the book.

    Associate professor Rabindra “Robby” Ratan shared advice with other professors about reaching and engaging students. Photo by Joe Grimm

    Associate professor Rabindra “Robby” Ratan shared advice with other professors about reaching and engaging students. Photo courtesy of Joe Grimm.

    18 Students, 50+ Chapters, 230 Pages

    By writing three chapters each, 18 students were able to cover about 50 issues and fill 230 pages. Chapters include:

    • Profane professors: Tactical or tacky?
    • A professor walks into a classroom: Humor 101
    • PowerPoint: weapon of class destruction
    • Commuter students in the classroom
    • When racial conflict breaks out in the classroom
    • #BlackOnCampus is about what goes on inside classrooms, too
    • ‘I hope you’re not hiding any guns under your headscarf today’

    After the book came out, the new authors described their experience in emails.

    Meaghan Markey wrote, “I never knew I could feel anxiety and excitement at the same time. You get so worked up over an approximately 500-word article and the more you dig for information the more you uncover. This gives you so much anxiety because you feel like it never ends, but at the same time it is so exciting because you learn so much! When you talk out loud with a team that is when the best ideas are inspired.”

    Palak Sabbineni wrote: “This class was very insightful in terms of bringing to light all the issues concerning students, professors and university professionals. It has made me more empathetic in many ways.”

    Natalie Kozma, who was intervewed about the project on Michigan Radio wrote: “Interviewing professors and students for this book was eye-opening. Some were apathetic to our project, and that alarmed me.  From the start, we knew that the professors who didn’t want to learn or adapt their teaching styles wouldn’t be our readers — though they likely need our book the most. Others were inspired, and that fueled me to produce better work.”

    Not For Everyone

    Several professors declined free copies of the book. Not everyone who accepted one liked it. MSU Advertising and Public Relations professor Robert Kolt read the book and then stabbed an email into his iPhone: “… it was an easy read, well-written, several of my talented former students contributed and made me proud, and I didn’t put the book down.

    “I completed reading the book this afternoon. You had said at the faculty meeting that you were interested in faculty feedback.

    “No insult intended, but I didn’t like the book at all. I have no doubt many of the awkward things that were described in the book did in fact happen, but I just didn’t see it. Seriously, in my 24 years teaching at MSU, I can only recall one or two very minor incidents that were even remotely similar to any events described in the book. I solve problems every day, so taking positive action quickly to achieve good results just seems natural. … The most rewarding thing about teaching is developing great friendships with students that have lasted my lifetime.

    “I’ll give you your book back, I would prefer not to keep it in my library.”

    Rewarding Insights

    Others, lots of others, bought the book. In October, the book sold 218 copies on Amazon and briefly rose to No. 386 among all Amazon books. In December, Bryant and Stratton College in Buffalo ordered 34 copies for its faculty.

    The book has helped at least one professor: this editor. Now, I spend more time in class and office hours to get to know my students better. I demand more. We have about 10 strategies to discourage plagiarism and fabrication. I try not to assume too much because the project taught me that every student has a different story.

    What about you? What could students tell you about great college teaching?

    Free offer: I will send a free digital edition of the book to anyone who emails me and agrees to read it and post an Amazon review or respond to a survey about it.

    Joe Grimm is visiting editor in residence in the Michigan State University School of Journalism. He teaches reporting, editing, career branding and his students publish a series of guides to cultural competence as Bias Busters. Before joining MSU in 2008, Grimm worked at the Detroit Free Press for more than 25 years, 18 of them as the @newsrecruiter.

    Tagged: books diversity inclusion michigan state plagiarism publishing teaching Veterans

    Comments are closed.

  • About EducationShift

    EducationShift aims to move journalism education forward with coverage of innovation in the classroom as journalism and communications schools around the globe are coping with massive technological change. The project includes a website, bi-weekly Twitter chats at #EdShift, mixers and workshops, and webinars for educators.
    Amanda Bright: Education Curator
    Mark Glaser: Executive Editor
    Design: Vega Project

    MediaShift received a grant from the Knight Foundation to revamp its EducationShift section to focus on change in journalism education.
  • Who We Are

    MediaShift is the premier destination for insight and analysis at the intersection of media and technology. The MediaShift network includes MediaShift, EducationShift, MetricShift and Idea Lab, as well as workshops and weekend hackathons, email newsletters, a weekly podcast and a series of DigitalEd online trainings.

    About MediaShift »
    Contact us »
    Sponsor MediaShift »
    MediaShift Newsletters »

    Follow us on Social Media