How can journalists fight the war on journalism, both in the U.S. and abroad? As governments hunt down whistleblowers, leakers and journalists alike, many reporters are worried they now work in a world that criminalizes their profession, calling this a “DEFCON 2 journalism event.” Most recently, Chelsea (formerly known as Bradley) Manning, the source of the Wikileaks disclosures three years ago was sentenced to 35 years in prison, and David Miranda was detained in Heathrow airport for nine hours while helping his partner, the Guardian’s Glenn Greenwald, obtain documents related to NSA spying. How worried should journalists be when reporting on political, international affairs or national security? How should journalists work in the surveillance state and continue to report? This week’s Mediatwits will feature Tow Center director and former Guardian editor Emily Bell, NYU J-school professor and PressThink blogger Jay Rosen and Free Press’ Josh Stearns. MediaShift’s Mark Glaser hosts, along with Ana Marie Cox from The Guardian, Mónica Guzmán from the Seattle Times and GeekWire and Andrew Lih from American University.
Watch or listen to the podcast here:
Subscribe to the MediaShift audio podcast here.
Listen to the Mediatwits and follow us on SoundCloud!
Thanks to SoundCloud for providing audio support. Subscribe to the Mediatwits audio version via iTunes.
Follow @TheMediatwits on Twitter.
Ana Marie Cox is a senior political columnist for The Guardian. She is the founding editor of the Wonkette blog and has covered politics and the culture of Washington, D.C. for outlets including the Washington Post, Playboy, GQ, Mother Jones and Elle. She is the author of the novel “Dog Days” and lives in St. Paul, Minn. Follow her on Twitter @anamariecox.
Mark Glaser is executive editor of MediaShift and Idea Lab. He is a longtime freelance writer and editor, who has contributed to magazines such as Entertainment Weekly, Wired and Conde Nast Traveler, and websites such as CNET and the Yale Global Forum. He lives in San Francisco with his wife Renee and son Julian. You can follow him on Twitter @mediatwit.
Mónica Guzmán is a columnist for the Seattle Times and Northwest tech news site GeekWire and a community strategist for startups and media. She emcees Ignite Seattle, a grab-bag community-fueled speaker series. Mónica was a reporter at the Seattle Post-Intelligencer and seattlepi.com, its online-only successor, where she ran the experimental and award-winning Big Blog and drew a community of readers with online conversation and weekly meetups. Follow her on Twitter @moniguzman.
Andrew Lih is a new media journalist and associate professor of journalism at the American University School of Communication. He is the author of “The Wikipedia Revolution” (Hyperion 2009, Aurum UK 2009) and is a noted expert on online collaboration and journalism. He is a veteran of AT&T Bell Laboratories and in 1994 created the first online city guide for New York City (www.ny.com). Follow him on Twitter @fuzheado and buy his book here.
Emily Bell is the director of the Tow Center for Digital Journalism at the Columbia Journalism School. Previously, she was director of digital content for Britain’s Guardian News and Media from 2006 to 2010 and editor-in-chief of Guardian Unlimited from 2001 to 2006. Under Bell, the Guardian received numerous awards, including the Webby Award for a newspaper website in 2005, 2006, 2007 and 2009, and British Press Awards for Website of the Year in 2006, 2008 and 2009. Bell first joined the Observer newspaper, which became part of Guardian News and Media, in 1990, as a business reporter specializing in media business, marketing and technology. Bell is a leading media commentator in the U.K., writing about broadcasting and media policy issues. She is a 1987 graduate of Christ Church, Oxford University, where she earned a master’s degree in jurisprudence.
Jay Rosen has been on the faculty of New York University’s Arthur L. Carter Journalism Institute since 1986, and from 1999 to 2005 he served as chair of the department. Rosen is the author of PressThink, a blog about journalism and its ordeals. He also blogs at the Huffington Post. In July 2006 he announced the debut NewAssignment.Net, his experimental site for pro-am, open source reporting projects. The first one was called Assignment Zero, a collaboration with Wired.com. A second project is OfftheBus.Net with the Huffington Post. Rosen is also a member of the Wikipedia Advisory Board. He’s the author of “What Are Journalists For?,” which is about the rise of the civic journalism movement. From 1993 to 1997 he was the director of the Project on Public Life and the Press, funded by the Knight Foundation. As a press critic and reviewer, he has published in The Nation, Columbia Journalism Review, the Chronicle of Higher Education, The New York Times, the Washington Post, the Los Angeles Times, Newsday, Salon.com, TomPaine.com and Poynter.org.
Josh Stearns is a journalist, organizer and community strategist. He is Journalism and Public Media Campaign Director for Free Press, a national, non-partisan, non-profit organization working to reform the media through education, organizing and advocacy. He was a co-author of “Saving the News: Toward a national journalism strategy,” “Outsourcing the News: How covert consolidation is destroying newsrooms and circumventing media ownership rules,” and “On the Chopping Block: State budget battles and the future of public media.” Find him on Twitter at @jcstearns.
1. Journalists and sources targeted in leak investigations, shield law could be weak
Earlier this summer, the Associated Press revealed that DOJ had obtained phone records of numerous AP reporters with the hope of prosecuting a leaker. Fox News reporter James Rosen was named a “an aider, abettor and/or co-conspirator” in a leak investigation, and DOJ is compelling New York Times reporter James Risen to testify against a source in a similar investigation. Chelsea (formerly known as Bradley) Manning was sentenced to 35 years in prison for releasing classified information to WikiLeaks. The ACLU and other free speech advocates have criticized the government for detaining the whistleblower, somebody who helped shed light on the war in Iraq and international governmental affairs. Meanwhile, NSA leaker Edward Snowden is still in Russia avoiding prosecution by the U.S., and WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange is in the Ecuadorian embassy in London avoiding extradition to Sweden. In response to journalists’ outcry, President Barack Obama has promised a new national shield law to protect reporters. However, the protection would exclude bloggers, who “commit acts of journalism” too. It would also create loopholes for national security reporting probes, doing little to prevent investigations like those mentioned. There are ways to improve the shield law, but will the U.S. government listen?
2. U.K. government attacks the Guardian
As the primary publisher of disclosures of NSA spying practices (which pose their own First Amendment concerns), the Guardian has been under pressure by the U.K. government to stop printing stories based on documents provided by contractor Edward Snowden. Some of their tactics include destroying the British paper’s hard drives and detaining Guardian journalist Glenn Greenwald’s partner David Miranda, both of which carried evidence of the extent of NSA surveillance.
A little over two months ago I was contacted by a very senior government official claiming to represent the views of the prime minister. There followed two meetings in which he demanded the return or destruction of all the material we were working on. The tone was steely, if cordial, but there was an implicit threat that others within government and Whitehall favored a far more draconian approach. The mood toughened just over a month ago, when I received a phone call from the center of government telling me: “You’ve had your fun. Now we want the stuff back.”
– Guardian editor Alan Rusbridger
3. What happens when journalists fight journalists
Not all journalists seem as bothered by the pursuit of Edward Snowden or of talks of criminalization of journalism. Jeffrey Toobin of CNN and the New Yorker was criticized by the press for referring to Miranda as a “drug mule” and calling for Snowden’s arrest, and CNN’s Piers Morgan also criticized Snowden’s actions. Before that, NBC’s “Meet the Press” host David Gregory was attacked for asking Greenwald if he should be charged with espionage for his reporting. Michael Grunwald, a TIME national correspondent tweeted that he couldn’t “wait to write a defense of the drone strike that takes out Julian Assange.”
Don’t forget to vote in our weekly MediaShift poll: