Google News announced it would start experimenting with a new feature that allows the sources in articles it aggregates to write comments, extending the smallish quotes that usually run with stories with more context and details. On the face, it sounds like a good idea, as anything that will provide more depth to journalism should be applauded. However, there’s been a bit of an uproar over Google trying to “own” these comments by putting them only on the Google News site and not on the sites where the articles come from. Google says it will verify that the people commenting were indeed mentioned or quoted in the article before allowing comments. What do you think of this idea? Is this a service to journalism, or is it another move by an online company to steal mindshare and traffic from traditional sources of journalism? What features of this would work and what wouldn’t work? Share your thoughts in the comments below and I’ll run the best ones in the next Your Take Roundup.
What do you think about comments on Google News stories?
Mediatwits Google Hangout
Mediatwits on SoundCloud
MediaShift delivers the best news on media and technology directly to your in-box.
Best of Mediashift
- Special Series: Redefining Engagement
- Engagement is Relational, not Transactional
- Thinking of Starting a Podcast? Read This First
- 10 Predictions for Media Metrics in 2016
- Journalism Education's Big Miss: Ignoring the Business Side
- Special Series: Inside the Content Marketing Boom
- The Rise of the Engagement Editor and What It Means
- How Quartz is Bringing Storytelling, Interactive Design to Sponsored Content
- DigitalEd: How to Personalize Your Content for Better Engagement
Get MediaShift Daily via Email
Follow us on Social
Who we Are
MediaShift explains how traditional media such as newspapers, magazines, radio, TV, music and movies are changing with digital disruption and adapting their business models for a more mobile, networked world.
If you're interested in submitting a guest column, see our guidelines here.