Mediatwits #163: Can We Slow Online Harassment Without Curbing Free Speech?

    by Jefferson Yen
    June 5, 2015
    Maeve Duggan, a research analyst at Pew, explains how people react to internet trolls.

    The rise of the Internet has given more people the ability to express and share their thoughts. Social media platforms such as Facebook and Twitter have helped like-minded people find each other and reach wider audiences. Unfortunately, that access means that bad actors and trolls can also use the platforms to threaten or harass others. A disportionate amount of those have been young women. Of those women, 26 percent reported being stalked online while a quarter experienced sexual harassment online. Earlier this week, the Supreme Court ruled on the case of Elonis v. U.S. Anthony Elonis was convicted of violating a federal threat statute after he posted violent messages about his estranged wife on Facebook. The Supreme Court overturned Elonis’ conviction, with Chief Justice John Roberts stating that a reasonable person standard is “inconsistent with the conventional criminal conduct requirement of ‘awareness of some wrongdoing.’” We’ll explain what that means this week on the Mediatwits podcast, with guests Jennifer Chen, freelance journalist; Maeve Duggan, research analyst at Pew Research; Jonathan Peters, assistant professor of journalism at the University of Kansas; and regular guest Andrew Lih at American University. MediaShift’s Mark Glaser is the host and Jefferson Yen is producing.

    Don’t have a lot of time to spare but still want to listen to the Mediatwits? Then check out our Digital Media Brief below!

    "It's going to raise the burden of proof on prosecutors" ~ Jonathan Peters on the practical implications of Elonis v. U.S.

    Mediatwits: Full Episode


    Digital Media Brief

    Listen to the Mediatwits and follow us on SoundCloud! Thanks to SoundCloud for providing audio support.

    Subscribe to the Mediatwits audio version via iTunes.


    Follow @TheMediatwits on Twitter.

    Subscribe to our YouTube Channel.


    mark-glaser-ISOJ-headshot-150x150Mark Glaser is executive editor of MediaShift and Idea Lab. He is a longtime freelance writer and editor, who has contributed to magazines such as Entertainment Weekly, Wired, and Conde Nast Traveler, and websites such as CNET and the Yale Global Forum. He lives in San Francisco with his wife Renee and son Julian. You can follow him on Twitter @mediatwit. AndrewLih_270x210

    Andrew Lih is a new media journalist and associate professor of journalism at the American University School of Communication. He is the author of “The Wikipedia Revolution” (Hyperion 2009, Aurum UK 2009) and is a noted expert on online collaboration and journalism. He is a veteran of AT&T Bell Laboratories and in 1994 created the first online city guide for New York City (www.ny.com). Follow him on Twitter @fuzheado.


    Jennifer Chen is a Los Angeles-based freelance writer who has written for Pacific Standard, BuzzFeed, Cosmopolitan, Real Simple, O: The Oprah Magazine, and several other publications. In addition to her freelance work, she is a young adult writer represented by Regal Literary in New York City. Currently, she serves as an artistic committee member for The Blank, a local LA theater. She blogs regularly at jchenwriter.com and can be found on Twitter and Instagram @jchenwriter

    Maeve Duggan is a research analyst at the Pew Research Center. Through public opinion research, her work investigates the impact of the internet and technology on American societal trends. Most recently, she authored a nationally-representative study of the prevalence and patterns of online harassment. Other research topics include social media use, mobile technology, the demographics of technology access, teens and technology use, health, and online dating. Duggan holds a master’s in Media and Public Affairs from the George Washington University, where she also graduated summa cum laude with a Bachelor’s in Political Communication. She tweets @maeveyd

    Jonathan Peters is an assistant professor of journalism at the University of Kansas, where he specializes in media law and policy, with an affiliate research position exploring big data in the KU Information & Telecommunication Technology Center. An attorney and the press freedom correspondent for the Columbia Journalism Review, Peters has blogged about free expression for the Harvard Law & Policy Review, and he has written on legal issues for EsquireThe AtlanticSlateThe NationWired and PBS. Peters is the First Amendment chair of the American Bar Association’s Civil Rights Litigation Committee, and he is the teaching chair of the Law and Policy Division of the Association for Education in Journalism and Mass Communication. Find him @jonathanwpeters


    You don’t have to search very hard to find instances of harassment online. According to Pew Research, 4 in 10 people have been harassed online. One of the most visible instances of online harassment occurred last year relating to “Gamergate.” When it was still active, prominent women in games including feminist critic Anita Sarkeesian and game developers Brianna Wu and Zoe Quinn were sent messages threatening rape, death, and the release of personal information. But as journalist Alanah Pearce discovered, it’s not just adults making those threats. Last year, her story went viral when she started contacting the mothers of her adolescent abusers. Nor is all the harassment from men. Isabella Sorley was sentenced to 12 weeks in a London jail for sending harassing tweets.

    Elonis v. U.S. is the first case concerning free speech and social media the Supreme Court has taken. While social media companies have been hesitant to curb such behavior citing the principles of free speech, some had hoped that governments could provide a legal framework for curbing harassment online. Elonis contested his conviction on the grounds of free speech. Only two justices dissented from the majority opinion — Justice Samuel Alito and Justice Clarence Thomas. Alito took the Court to task, writing “The court refuses to explain what type of intent was necessary. Was it enough if he knew that his words conveyed such a threat?” The Supreme Court will let a lower court decide whether or not Elonis intended and meant for others to perceive his messages as a threat.

    How should we curb online harassment? Where do we draw the line? How should we treat minors if they post threatening messages? And what role do social and online platforms play in moderating comments and blocking users?

    Jefferson Yen is the producer for the Mediatwits Podcast. His work has been on KPCC Southern California Public Radio and KRTS Marfa Public Radio. You can follow him @jeffersontyen.

    Tagged: censorship elonis v. u.s. facebook internet trolls online harassment sexual harassment social media supreme court twitter youtube

    One response to “Mediatwits #163: Can We Slow Online Harassment Without Curbing Free Speech?”

    1. hurin says:

      GamerGate is still active thak you, and will continue to be so. Someone needs to protect our hobby from the SJW’s who wants to censor our games, and since we can’t count on the media, we have to do it ourself. Expect GamerGate to be around for as long as it takes. This is a war of attrition, and we can grind for a lot longer than our opponents can.

      Brianna Wu is still faking her own harassment to get Pateon welfare, and Anita Sarkeesian (aka Jack Thompson with a vagina) is as irrelevant as ever.

      What are the top sellers on Steam right now? GTA5, Witcher 3, Hatred. All games Anita hates and thinks are ‘problematic’ whatever that means.

  • Who We Are

    MediaShift is the premier destination for insight and analysis at the intersection of media and technology. The MediaShift network includes MediaShift, EducationShift, MetricShift and Idea Lab, as well as workshops and weekend hackathons, email newsletters, a weekly podcast and a series of DigitalEd online trainings.

    About MediaShift »
    Contact us »
    Sponsor MediaShift »
    MediaShift Newsletters »

    Follow us on Social Media