Democracy Fund’s Map Points to Fragmented Local News Ecosystem, Barriers to Public Square

    by Ben DeJarnette
    April 13, 2016
    The Democracy Fund's local news "systems map" examines the factors that shape today's public square.

    Last month, as the national media continued to attract both attention and scorn for its sensational coverage of the 2016 presidential election circus, the Democracy Fund cast a spotlight on another, less ballyhooed pillar of American journalism: local news.

    The centerpiece of the Democracy Fund’s new Local News & Participation project is an interactive systems map that visualizes how citizens gain information and participate in democracy. Version 1.0 of the map notes that, among other trends, the ability of news organizations to create inclusive public squares is diminishing, as partisanship and personalized content produce fragmented “echo chambers” instead. 

    "The public square used to consist of a small number of large outlets, but as the world becomes more digital, we’re ending up with a larger number of smaller outlets." -Tom Glaisyer

    Arguably, the map’s focus on local news systems couldn’t come at a more important time. In recent years, successful media startups like Vox and BuzzFeed may have boosted optimism for the future of national news, but local journalism has remained in a rut, with continued newsroom cuts leaving deep gaps in public accountability journalism. As Alana Semuels shrewdly observed for The Atlantic, local news outlets face steeper digital-era challenges than do their counterparts in the national media:


    “The fastest-growing sites focus on national or international topics like Congress’s agenda, military interventions in the Middle East, economic trends in the U.S., or more salacious news, like a woman who was run over by her own car when her dog lifted the brake,” Semuels wrote. “It’s a necessary part of doing business: If you want to attract enough readers to lure companies into paying for web ads, it’s tough to limit your coverage to just one city or neighborhood.”

    With its systems map, the Democracy Fund joins a host of other organizations, including the Dodge Foundation, the Agora Journalism Center, Journalism that Matters and the Center for Collaborative Journalism, that are trying to point the way toward solutions for local news. Tom Glaisyer, program director for the Democracy Fund, says the goal in this case is to help journalists better understand the modern news ecosystem and how it informs civic life.

    “The map gives us a more integrated view of how multiple dynamics are reinforcing or countering each other,” he said. “It allows us to look at the interrelationships.”


    The Public Square

    One question raised by the map is how journalists can facilitate a public square in a media ecosystem that’s becoming increasingly fragmented. The interactive map helps show how various factors, including partisanship, advertising-based business models and social media algorithms, contribute to the “echo chamber” effect that distances citizens from diverse perspectives.  

    A screenshot from The Democracy Fund's local news systems map.

    A screenshot from The Democracy Fund’s local news systems map.

    “The public square used to consist of a small number of large outlets with great reach, but as the world becomes more digital, we’re ending up with a larger number of smaller outlets,” Glaisyer said. “You get a wider range of voices, but the question is how much we’re listening to voices with which we disagree? And how do journalists create that interchange?

    Glaisyer acknowledges that the map does more to “pose questions back to us” than to offer solutions for the challenges facing local news organizations. But notably, the project does come at a moment when interest — and investment — in the future of local news appear to be surging. From Josh Stearns’ and Molly de Aguiar’s newsletter The Local Fix to the community journalism courses popping up at J-schools to the experimental initiatives launched recently by both Gannett and Advance, the media space is becoming crowded with efforts to reinvigorate journalism at the local level. Even Hollywood is paying attention to local news (see: “Spotlight“), reminding viewers what public accountability journalism can accomplish at its very best.  

    Overall, these developments should offer cause for optimism. Sure, big questions remain about how to fund journalism and how to create the public sphere in a digital environment. But as evidenced by the Democracy Fund’s systems map and its Local News & Participation project, these questions are increasingly getting the attention they deserve.

    Ben DeJarnette is the associate editor at MediaShift. He is also a freelance contributor for Pacific Standard, InvestigateWest, Men’s Journal, Runner’s World, Oregon Quarterly and others. He’s on Twitter @BenDJduck.


    Tagged: Agora Journalism Center center for collaborative journalism civic engagement dodge foundation journalism that matters local news public square The Democracy Fund tom glaisyer

    Comments are closed.

  • Who We Are

    MediaShift is the premier destination for insight and analysis at the intersection of media and technology. The MediaShift network includes MediaShift, EducationShift, MetricShift and Idea Lab, as well as workshops and weekend hackathons, email newsletters, a weekly podcast and a series of DigitalEd online trainings.

    About MediaShift »
    Contact us »
    Sponsor MediaShift »
    MediaShift Newsletters »

    Follow us on Social Media