Pre-Internet days, a newspaper in Denmark that printed cartoons could be assured that they wouldn’t be seen in other parts of the world. Those days are over. With protests and riots still burning bright in the Middle East over cartoons depicting Mohammed, we cannot ignore our global neighbors even if they live on the other side of the world. As newspapers in the U.S. consider whether to run the cartoons, simple searches online can show anyone what the fuss is about.
But after weeks and even months of frustrating conflict over the issue, where can people vent their frustrations in a safe way? Where can they perhaps find common ground?
One surprising place was in a forum run by Topix.net, a news aggregator that until recently was known for collecting all the local news for thousands of locales. The site, now majority owned by three newspaper chains, added moderated forums last December, and found itself quickly swamped in the Mohammed cartoon controversy. The Denmark Forum became ground zero for arguments and discussion that eminated from around the world — from the United Arab Emirates and Libya to the UK and Oklahoma City.
Topix.net CEO Rich Skrenta (pictured here) wrote on his blog that the thing to do when the discussion gets hot is not to shut it down (like Washingtonpost.com had to do) but to keep it going. So if you skim through the Denmark Forum, you’ll find plenty of flames, personal attacks, and four-letter words sprinkled through the discussions.
But Topix.net does indeed moderate the forums, and even added one killer feature: The site uses geolocation to pinpoint where forum participants are posting from. And that location is displayed below your screen name, so you can’t pretend to be in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, when your location is really Atlanta, Georgia. Just that one simple feature took some of the anonymous flaming and hoaxing out of the discussions, making them stronger.
Though the discussions on the Denmark Forum are dominated by hateful and ignorant people, the fact that they are even together, exposed to other points of view, can’t help but make them less ignorant. At one point, a Saudi in London condemned the attacks on embassies and other violence by Muslims, which brought a round of sympathy from the other participants. At various points, people do try to find common ground.
The following is an email Q&A that I had with Skrenta of Topix.net. He told me more about how Topix.net moderates its forums and how this type of open global discussion — warts and all — can promote more understanding.
Q: When did you launch news forums, and how many postings have you had?
Rich Skrenta: We launched the community participation system on Dec. 12, 2005. We’ve had 48,000 posts as of today. The highest posting day so far had 4,000 posts; on average we’re getting approximately 3,500 posts per day.
Q: How do you moderate them? How much is technology filters and how much is human oversight?
Skrenta: We have a combination of software filters and human moderation on the forums. About half of the posts being moderated are being done by software and the other half by human review. The tools for moderators to use to deal with bad posts are pretty good, so it’s easy to scan a large number of posts in a short time and deal with problem users quickly. Our goal with the moderation tools was to make the moderators as productive as possible so the system could scale to hundreds of thousands of posts per day. We have experience building large-scale systems of this sort in the past at Netscape/AOL.
We don’t like to see bad posts on our forums; at the same time, there is such a vast gray area between the obvious spam and trolls and the clearly reasonable posts, that it really makes you start to question what your role should be in censoring opinions that are being expressed. Perhaps they are strongly expressed, heated opinions, but someone took the time to participate. Maybe they used some four letter words to express themselves, but it’s in a three paragraph post that makes some points. What do you do? How do we choose where to draw the line? Is there a list of words you can’t say? Ideas you can’t express? Should I be deleting a post simply because someone is “yelling” online?
Our Denmark forums are a real trial-by-fire. We had some heated threads before this but getting 15,000 posts in a week over a global issue such as this was unexpected. I’m glad that we were able to keep our system running OK through this. We’ve already made some changes to our filters and adding a few new moderation tools as a result of this experience.
Q: Do you worry about legal issues, slander and libel?
Skrenta: We reviewed our system prior to launch with our lawyers and are comfortable with our approach.
Q: How exact is your geolocation technology? Have people complained their location was wrong?
Skrenta: The geolocation technology we use is 99% accurate on a country level, 80% accurate on a state level, and 75% accurate for U.S. cities. Often for a wrong city it still gets the right “neck of the woods” for a poster. It says I’m in San Francisco when I’m actually in Palo Alto. It is finding the location of the poster’s ISP, not the poster themselves, which can be surprising.
A big benefit, though, apart from the geo-approximation of the poster, is that, since it’s not generally practical to forge, the location is a second handle on the poster’s identity apart from who they’re claiming to be. So if someone posting from Riyahd claims they’re an American living in Chicago, it’s easy to see that they’re probably not telling the truth. It also helps contain identity masquerading in the forums. A user can log out and log in again and change their username but it’s
often easy to spot them since they’re posting from the same location. The geolocation “outed” a number of posters who had been pretending to be a number of different people.
No one has really complained about it. One person in a thread I saw was confused why a different city than where they lived was showing up, another posted said that was probably their ISP’s home office address. Overall the texture of the forum experience seems to have been improved and there hasn’t been any backlash.
Q: What do we gain as a global society to allow unfettered arguments to rage like this? Does it lead to greater understanding?
Skrenta: I think it does lead to greater understanding. There will always be those who choose not to discuss or listen, but where else can a suburban Californian go to debate a global issue with citizens from Iran and Lebanon and Saudi Arabia? We have to believe that open debate and discussion are ultimately positive and beneficial to humanity. It may not be perfect, but as the saying goes, it beats the alternative. Don’t build the system in the first place? Censor all the posts or shut it down? Only let a few tell the many what they’re allowed to hear? That’s not where we as a society want to go.
Topix, interestingly, being owned by newspaper companies may be the ideal entity to run a system such as this.
Q: Have you considered ways to summarize the best points of the highly trafficked forums to make it more readable for a broader audience?
Skrenta: Some kind of group voting system, to promote key posts? Perhaps… I don’t have a clear idea how to do that yet. Perhaps this is where journalists come in.
******
What do you think? I apologize again that our comments here at MediaShift were down the past couple days. They are working again, and please use them to share your thoughts. If you have questions for Skrenta, please ask them in the comments, and I will relay them to him.
View Comments (165)
Do you want to be a member of
the great brotherhood Illuminati?
we are going to make you rich
famous and to be a world known
star, get a good job, to win
elections and get into a political
power we are going to enrich you
in all your endeavours
empowerment and you will never
loose any case in court or were
ever, you will have powers to
control people in high places email
us now at illuminatispelltemple666@gmail .com,
or add us on our whatassp number +2348102799582
beware you must be 18 years and above if you
know you are not interested
never you attempt to this post be
warned
Do you want to be a member of
the great brotherhood Illuminati?
we are going to make you rich
famous and to be a world known
star, get a good job, to win
elections and get into a political
power we are going to enrich you
in all your endeavours
empowerment and you will never
loose any case in court or were
ever, you will have powers to
control people in high places email
us now at illuminatispelltemple666@gmail .com,
or add us on our whatassp number +2348102799582
beware you must be 18 years and above if you
know you are not interested
never you attempt to this post be
warned..
ARTISTS,POLITICIANS,PASTOR,ENGINEER,DOCTOR, STUDENTS,
GRADUATED and you want to become Rich Powerful and famous,
in life or,Are you frustrated in life. What type of wealth do you
want? Today is your luckiest day, 'I want to join great Illuminati
occult in Nigeria' we are here for those of you that want to join
Illuminati Brotherhood in Nigeria and across Africa.Are you tired of
poverty and now you want fame,power and riches Making wealth is
guaranteed for the people of the world. Our magical powers are
beyond your imagination. we could do magic on your behalf
regarding , your financial situation, future events, or whatever is
important to you. we have the power and we use the power.Life is
a game. Money is how we keep scores. Money speaks sense in a
language all nations understand. If you would know the value of
money, go and try to borrow some; for he that goes borrowing goes
sorrowing. We are a group of strong brothers who came from
different walks of life for the purpose of alleviating the sufferings
of our people we are Illuminati, and we could change the course of
destiny Illuminati Brotherhood are most probably the most well
known secret society in the world. Illuminati Brotherhood is not for
Everyone, Is it someone or something you desire to have? Do you
want wealth(Want to grow your bank account?, Need funds to enjoy
the good life? Tired of working hard and getting nowhere?) or
happiness? the most powerful society welcomes you to
Illuminati..But we might be Right for you! We are Seeking our Dark
Brothers and Sisters who have heard the call to come Home to the
Illuminati Family! For those fortunate applicants of interest whom
will be chosen to join the succeeding family of Illuminati, you will
learn the untold secrets that few have ever known existed! The
Illuminati rituals for securing Wealth, Health, Love, Lust and Power
that none outside of this family have ever been taught and never
will. . . we are here to protect you if you so desire! .. contact Email... illuminatiworld46@gmail.com
Illuminati initiation home Send us your most important desire and
we shall work our powers in your favor. Be sure to tell Illuminati
what you want. What's app Now or call
the agent now +23408101333426. Whatsapp number
+2348101333426 you can whats app for
Immediate initiation. New members registration is now open online
Email... illuminatiworld46@gmail.com our source of wealth
and power is reviled to registered member only........Good Lucky
Man.....
TO BECOME A MEMBER OF THE THIS GREAT BROTHERHOOD IT EASY YOU JUST HAVE
TO FOLLOW THE RULES AND REGULATION IF YOU ARE INTERESTED INBOX US NOW
HERE ON FACEBOOK OR EMAIL VIA:SAMDOM@YAHOO.COM.
I am very surprise for the miraculous experience and wonders of Dr,ABU that have been spreading on the Internet and worldwide, How he marvellously helped people all over the world to restored back their lost lovers I contacted him after going through so many testimonies from different people how he help to bring back ex lovers i was deeply in love with my boyfriend and he was with me but suddenly one day he broke up with me. I tried everything but nothing seemed to workout, I thought it was going to be over forever.I never believed in spells but I was so desperate I thought I got nothing else to loose. I started searching for different spell casters and I finally found 'Great ABU Temple' who helped me through the process and I eventually got my boyfriend back and we are so happy together. I am so grateful to him. If you ever need a spell caster who can get you ex back and many more then contact him on [abu.s39spellcaster@yahoo.com],
I am very surprise for the miraculous experience and wonders of Dr,ABU that have been spreading on the Internet and worldwide, How he marvelously helped people all over the world to restored back their lost lovers I contacted him after going through so many testimonies from different people how he help to bring back ex lovers i was deeply in love with my boyfriend and he was with me but suddenly one day he broke up with me. I tried everything but nothing seemed to workout, I thought it was going to be over forever.I never believed in spells but I was so desperate I thought I got nothing else to loose. I started searching for different spell casters and I finally found 'Great ABU Temple' who helped me through the process and I eventually got my boyfriend back and we are so happy together. I am so grateful to him. If you ever need a spell caster who can get you ex back and many more then contact him on [abu.s39spellcaster@yahoo.com]
I will like to ask this question before i go straight to my public announcement out here. If getting a legit loan online was so easy as stated in all this fabricated / duplicated loan testimonies that i have been reading through online, then why was i and my lovely wife turned down for a loan online five times after been scammed of about $42000? am Stephen by name my public announcement is just how a very close family friend gave me and my wife an email of a reliable loan firm know as Quicken Loans. With a big surprise I got my loan amount worth $456,000. contact him with the following email: quickenloan01@gmail.com for your loan to be financially upright.
It's unbelievable how fortunate I feel after finding your website. For the past 4 months, I have been so depressed after losing my husband to another woman. My money situation worsened so much that I thought I'd have to file for bankruptcy. I had a huge amount of debt and I didn't know what to do. Out of complete and total desperation, I contacted many of those so-called individuals who promised powerful magic, witchcraft or black magic. None of them worked and none were as wonderful, affectionate and warm as Dr Marvel has been. He is definitely different from the others and I felt immediate hope and strength from hearing about the promises he had to offer. He carries an air of purity and divine strength that is as pure as fresh snow on the ground. I requested Dr UDUMA most powerful spells and I was relieved right away that I had someone to solve my problems for me. His spells worked wonders and I am now back with my husband and my money troubles resolved itself miraculously Dr UDUMA, I have no idea what I would have done without you being there to help me out. you can contact him via email dumamikolosolution2000@gmail.com for any problem you have sickness E.T.C for cure of any sickness.
INSTANT LOAN FINANCIAL SERVICE have been accredited by the Better Business Bureau after meeting all their strict requirements.
If you're looking for an unsecured loan from non-bank sources, look no further and contact INSTANT LOAN FINANCIAL SERVICE today for just 2%
interest rate because it's great place to start your search. Borrowing money online is a fast and convenient option, but always keep safe by choosing a
reputable lender to work with. On some occasions, people find themselves in life scenarios where they need to borrow money for different reasons. It may be to make a large purchase, buy new home furniture's, finance a long awaited vacation or even to consolidate other debt, including high-rate interest card debt.they wouldn't even mind about the interest rate,but Getting a secured bank loan to do this can be difficult at times and it's not always accessible to regular, everyday clients.
PRODUCTS AND SERVICES RENDERED INCLUDE THE FOLLOWING
Applications by Phone, Auto & Mobile Home Leasing, Auto Title Loans, Cash Loans, Confidential Loans, Loans!, Same Day Approval, Signature & Auto Title, State Licensed, Title Loans,Debt Consolidation Loan,
Further more ILFS is governed under the C.E.O leadership of Mr Thompson Campbell
Contact us today on and put a stop to your financial misery in just 24 hours
contact us now on
email:
instantloanfinancialservice5@gmail.com
You can also text or call us on +1-(619) 784-7625 for further Inquiries
Best Regards
Thompson Campbell
C.E.O
+2347018957098